This is general knowledge or an external-engine reference, not an Apollo architecture or implementation claim. See Apollo's architecture status for target terminology and verified implementation boundaries.
Q112: How to Communicate Technical Solutions with Designers?
Problem Analysis
This question tests cross-functional communication skills:
- Requirement understanding
- Solution explanation
- Feasibility assessment
- Collaborative delivery
1. Communication Principles
1.1 Communication Key Points
┌─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┐
│ Principles for Communicating with Designers │
├─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┤
│ │
│ Understand the requirement: │
│ ├── Understand the core fun │
│ ├── Clarify target users │
│ ├── Understand the expected effect │
│ └── Ask about boundary conditions │
│ │
│ Explain constraints: │
│ ├── Technical feasibility │
│ ├── Performance limits │
│ ├── Development cost │
│ └── Maintenance cost │
│ │
│ Provide solutions: │
│ ├── Core requirements first │
│ ├── Phased implementation │
│ ├── Alternative solutions │
│ └── Risk explanation │
│ │
│ Communicate continuously: │
│ ├── Regularly sync progress │
│ ├── Report issues promptly │
│ ├── Decide and adjust together │
│ └── Validate the expected effect │
│ │
└─────────────────────────────────────────────────────────────┘2. Requirement Analysis
2.1 Requirement Understanding Framework
python
# Requirement analysis framework
class RequirementAnalysis:
"""Requirement analysis"""
def analyze(self, requirement):
"""Analyze requirement"""
return {
'core_value': self._find_core_value(requirement),
'target_users': self._identify_target_users(requirement),
'success_metrics': self._define_success_metrics(requirement),
'constraints': self._identify_constraints(requirement),
'risks': self._assess_risks(requirement)
}
def _find_core_value(self, requirement):
"""Find core value"""
questions = [
"What problem does this feature solve?",
"What fun do players get?",
"What benefit does it bring to the game?"
]
# Discuss and answer these questions with the designer
return "Core value description"
def _identify_target_users(self, requirement):
"""Identify target users"""
return {
'player_type': 'newbie/veteran/paying/free',
'playstyle': 'casual/hardcore/social/competitive',
'expected_participation': 'Expected participation'
}
def _define_success_metrics(self, requirement):
"""Define success metrics"""
return {
'usage': 'Usage rate',
'retention': 'Retention impact',
'revenue': 'Revenue impact',
'engagement': 'Engagement'
}
# Requirement analysis example
"""
Designer proposes: "Implement cross-server trading"
Requirement analysis:
1. Core value:
- Enliven the economy
- Increase socializing
- Improve retention
2. Target users:
- Mid-to-high level players
- Players with trading needs
3. Success metrics:
- Transaction volume > 1000/day
- Participating players > 20%
- Complaints < 1%
4. Constraints:
- No item duping
- Performance must not be affected
- Anti-addiction limits required
5. Risk assessment:
- Economic system impact
- Cheat risk
- Customer support pressure
"""3. Solution Communication
3.1 Solution Presentation
python
# Solution communication framework
class SolutionPresentation:
"""Solution presentation"""
def present(self, requirement):
"""Present solution"""
return {
'understanding': self._show_understanding(requirement),
'approach': self._explain_approach(requirement),
'feasibility': self._assess_feasibility(requirement),
'timeline': self._estimate_timeline(requirement),
'tradeoffs': self._discuss_tradeoffs(requirement)
}
def _show_understanding(self, requirement):
"""Show understanding"""
return """
I understand your requirement as:
Core goal: {core goal}
Target users: {target users}
Expected effect: {expected effect}
Is my understanding correct?
"""
def _explain_approach(self, requirement):
"""Explain the solution"""
return """
Recommended solution:
Architecture design:
- Use a dedicated trading server
- Message queue for asynchronous processing
- Redis caching for hot data
Core flow:
1. Player lists items
2. Trading service validates
3. Database persistence
4. Broadcast updates
Security measures:
- Trade frequency limits
- Amount validation
- Logging
"""
def _assess_feasibility(self, requirement):
"""Assess feasibility"""
return {
'technical': 'Technical feasibility: High',
'performance': 'Performance impact: Low',
'security': 'Security risk: Medium, needs stronger validation',
'maintenance': 'Maintenance cost: Medium'
}
def _estimate_timeline(self, requirement):
"""Estimate timeline"""
return """
Timeline estimate:
Phase 1 (foundation): 2 weeks
- Architecture setup
- Basic functionality
- Internal testing
Phase 2 (features): 2 weeks
- Trading features
- Search features
- Integration testing
Phase 3 (optimization): 1 week
- Performance optimization
- Security hardening
- Launch preparation
Total: 5 weeks
"""
def _discuss_tradeoffs(self, requirement):
"""Discuss tradeoffs"""
return """
Solution options:
Option A: Simple and fast
Pros: Fast development, low cost
Cons: Limited features, poor extensibility
Option B: Complete solution (recommended)
Pros: Complete features, extensible
Cons: Longer development time, higher cost
Suggestion:
- Implement the core of Option B first
- Roll out in stages and validate the effect
- Decide follow-up investment based on data
"""4. Common Scenarios
4.1 Scenario Handling
python
# Common communication scenarios
class CommonScenarios:
"""Common scenarios"""
scenarios = {
'Feasibility_Question': {
'scenario': 'Designer asks "Can this be implemented?"',
'answer_framework': '''
1. Technically it can be implemented
2. But consider:
- Development cost: X weeks
- Performance impact: needs optimization
- Maintenance cost: needs a dedicated owner
3. Suggest implementing the core feature first and validating the effect
'''
},
'Change_Request': {
'scenario': 'Requirement changes mid-development',
'handling': '''
1. Understand the reason for the change
2. Assess the impact:
- Workload required for the change
- Impact on the schedule
- Impact on other features
3. Provide options:
- Accept all (delayed)
- Accept partially (phased)
- Reject (explain why)
'''
},
'Performance_Concern': {
'scenario': 'Designer worries about performance',
'explanation': '''
1. Show test data
2. Explain the optimization plan:
- Partitioned processing
- Cache optimization
- Asynchronous processing
3. Provide monitoring
4. Define a scaling plan
'''
},
'Timeline_Pressure': {
'scenario': 'Time is tight',
'handling': '''
1. Sort out priorities:
- Core features must be done
- Auxiliary features can be simplified
- Nice-to-haves can be deferred
2. Parallel development
3. Reuse existing solutions
4. Modest overtime (short term)
'''
}
}5. Communication Skills
5.1 Effective Communication
python
# Communication skills
class CommunicationSkills:
"""Communication skills"""
tips = {
'Use_Analogy': {
'tip': 'Use analogy',
'example': '''
Designer: "Why can't we synchronise all player positions in real time?"
Answer: "Imagine 1000 people talking in the same room at once —
could you make out what everyone is saying? It's the same for us;
players only need to see the people nearby."
'''
},
'Show_Not_Tell': {
'tip': 'Show rather than tell',
'example': 'Demonstrate a prototype/effect directly instead of just describing it'
},
'Provide_Options': {
'tip': 'Provide options',
'example': '''
"We have three options:
A: Fast but few features
B: Slow but complete features
C: A compromise
Which do you prefer?"
'''
},
'Focus_Value': {
'tip': 'Focus on value',
'example': '''
"This implementation is complex, but it delivers a better player experience,
and it is worth it in the long run."
'''
}
}6. Collaboration Process
6.1 Standard Process
Requirement review → Technical solution → Review confirmation → Development → Acceptance testing → Launch and operation
Requirement review:
- Designer explains the requirement
- Developers ask clarifying questions
- Confirm the understanding together
Technical solution:
- Developers design the solution
- Designer confirms the effect
- Assess development cost
Development:
- Regularly sync progress
- Report issues promptly
- Coordinate resources
Acceptance testing:
- Designer accepts the features
- Feed back the issue list
- Developers fix them
Launch and operation:
- Monitor data performance
- Collect player feedback
- Plan follow-up iterations7. Best Practices
7.1 Collaboration Advice
| Practice | Description |
|---|---|
| See it their way | Understand the designer's difficulties |
| Let data speak | Support decisions with data |
| Prototype first | Validate ideas quickly |
| Keep docs in sync | Keep information consistent |
| Timely feedback | Don't wait until the end to speak up |
| Build trust | Keep your promises |
8. Summary
Core of Communicating with Designers
Communicating with designers = understand requirements + explain constraints + provide solutions + collaborate continuously
- Understand requirements from their perspective
- Translate technical language into business language
- Offer several solution options
- Keep communication open